Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Posted by gaetanol z6NY (My Page) on
Tue, Aug 5, 08 at 11:02

I am growing Husky Cherry Tomatoes and I am very happy with them: The plants are early & productive, and the fruits are very tasty.

I plan on adding another variety of cherry tomatoes next year, and I thought I would solicit opinions from the members.

What's your favorite cherry tomato?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Sungold. Delicious, sweet and very prolific.

Husky Cherry has also been a good store bought one for me this year. I'm also growing (from seed) Aunt Ruby's Yellow, Brown Berry and Angora Super Sweet. But ARY and Brown Berry have yet to ripen.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

It depends on what I'm going to use it for. So my favorites are SuperSweet 100, Sungold, Black Cherry, and Randy's Cherry Bomb.

I also have a suspicion and a suggestion. I suspect a lot of favorites will be Sungold, Black Cherry, and one of the sweets (Sweet 100, Sugary, etc.). The suggestion is to pick say Sungold next year, Black Cherry the following year etc. Trying is the real way to find out what you're going to like because of your personal taste and specific conditions (environmental factors).

Good luck and have fun.

Randy


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I am growing snow white cherry this year. It is nice and tomatoey with some tang. I really like them and will probably grow it next year along with some kind of sweet cherry...


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Sungold for me. Though i've grown few other varieties, it's easily been my favorite and most trouble free, nonstop producer. Makes a crazy good salsa too.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Matt's Mexican Wild for me; about 1/2 " with the most complex taste. Regards, Peter


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

  • Posted by doof SoCal 10a (My Page) on
    Wed, Aug 6, 08 at 23:06

Snow White is pretty good. Not dazzling, but pretty good. The best thing about it is the way it looks. It makes a nice contrast when you're growing more than one type of cherry tomato.

I would say my two favorites right now are Black Cherry and Gardener's Delight (a small red cherry).


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Sun Gold, Black Cherry, Gardener's Delight are my favorites, at this time.
I am also growing Matt's Wild Cherry(good taste, but tiny), Reisentraube(nothing yet), Green Grape(nothing yet), Super Sweet 100's(good, but very small), Camp Joy/Chadwick's Cherry(nothing yet), and Brown Berry(nothing yet). Kind of my own test to find the right ones 'cause I plant way too many every year. Unfortunately, I have liked every one I have tried so far. :-)
JMO,
Tom


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Our favorite "cherry" is actually yellow pear. Fun shape, color contrast, and the kids fight over who's turn it is to pick/eat them. We're tasting/trying different tomatoes and this one makes the cut with the kids every year.

*note*
For our trials, we score them 1-5, and at the end of the year take a look at which we liked best. YP gets 5's across the board from the kids, and is a 4.5 to hubby.

Here is a link that might be useful: yellow pear


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

My favorite cherries are Sungold, Sun Cherry (another sweet hybrid), and Black Cherry (which has a very unique, but sweet flavor). I'm growing way too many cherries this year. Snow White is also good (and very attractive), and everyone else but me loves Coyote. I personally didn't find it to be bad, it just doesn't taste like a tomato! Sweet 100 and Sweet Million are also very good, but are too similar to Sun Cherry.

If you're interested in some Coyote seeds, I'm saving tons and tons right now! Anything that doesn't get eaten is getting its seeds saved so...


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

From the standpoint of open pollinated cherry tomatoes (so you can save the seeds and repeat):

Red: Gardener's Delight/Sugar Lump (sweet and tomatoey)
Gold: Chello (almost as good as Sungold F1)
Purple: Black Cherry (damned hard to beat)


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I've got to give it to black cherry. Early on I was very sceptical and figured that no cherry tomato could be really good. I was wrong. Flat out the best fruity flavor I've ever experienced in a tomato. You've got to try Black Cherry, really.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I am growing both Black Cherry and Matt's Wild Cherry. They both are very good and full of flavor.

Dean


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Green Grape!!! Absolutely delicious when golden-ripe!

Carla in Sac


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

My favorite cherry tomato is sunsugar, it has all of the taste of sungold, but it doesn't seem prone to cracking, even with all of the heavy rain we've been having.

My second favorite is Black Cherry, an interesting color and taste.

PJ


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

We grew 6 Cherry varieties this yr.

I like Red Robin for its compact plant and earlyness but Gardener's Delight tastes better.

My Wife prefers Sprite and Black Cherry. She likes em sweet.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

  • Posted by doof SoCal 10a (My Page) on
    Fri, Aug 8, 08 at 22:25

Dave, if you like sweet, you might like Brown Berry even more than Black Cherry. It tends to be sweeter and fleshier. They're both great.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

SunSugar F1 (better than Sungold im my opinionm and does not crack as badly as Sungold)

Madara - the best open-pollinated yellow/orange cherry I tried so far. Not commonly grown, but deserves better.

Here is a link that might be useful: Madara


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I like SunSugar as well, I grew these last year and people went nuts for them. SunGold tastes a little more like a tomato, but if you want something sweet and delicious this one is excellent.

http://www.tomatogrowers.com/orange.htm, scroll down to SunSugar FT Hybrid

And no offense to person that suggested yellow pear, but it is a complete waste of garden space, looks nice but not worth eating at all. Just about the worst that I have ever tasted.

Black cherry also hard to beat. If you want a smaller fruit, I suggest Hawaiian Currant...size of a large pea, tastes great (very tomatoes for a small variety, moreso than any other currant variety that I have tried).


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I think you only need to grow one red cherry and if you're happy with Husky then add some diff. colors.

My favorites:
White: Dr. Carolyn-large ivory with very nice taste
Black: Black Cherry (of course)
Yellow: Yellow Pear-I LIKE the taste

What a pretty salad that is :-)


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Sun Sugar and Black Cherry.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

  • Posted by doof SoCal 10a (My Page) on
    Sun, Aug 10, 08 at 1:07

Yellow pear IS very attractive. I've never grown it, and none that I have ever tasted were worth eating. But it occurs to me that it might be a good base for some hybrid experiments, if you could keep the shape and appearance and cross it with something to give it a better flavor.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Try Yellow Submarine. It is a potato leaf pear shaped yellow tomato very similar to Yellow Pear, but with dramatically better flavor.

My overall best cherries are:
Camp Joy
Besser
Galina
Sungold
Black Cherry
Dr. Carolyn
Dr. Carolyn Pink
Green Grape
Sweet Quartz
Quartz Multiflora

I like to grow Ildi because of the way it flowers, but it is pretty poor in the flavor dept.

Next year I will be trialing a sungold lookalike that has stripes like green zebra.

DarJones


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Super Sweet 100 is both delicious and disease resistant. Sungold was great before it got disease. It did not hold up well at all to disease, and afterwards they tasted horrible.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Sungold and Supersweet 100. They are so sweet. Easy to grow-- no diseases and beautiful.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Sundrop Ripening
Sun Gold

Sun Gold Tomato
Sun Gold


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I agree with most of the other posters:

Best hybrid - SunGold
Best OP - Black Cherry.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Another vote for Galina. This year with plenty of regular rain, it is superb here in zone 5 with large plants and high yield. Other years it has been disappointing in size and yield, but not in flavor. A good meaty yellow/gold.

Sara Jane


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

  • Posted by doof SoCal 10a (My Page) on
    Mon, Aug 11, 08 at 17:35

God, I hated the taste of Galina's. The only other tomato I hated as much was Dr. Carolyn Pink Cherry, which is derived from Galina's. People's tastes are so different.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Me and my family like Sweet Millions the best. Very sugary and productive.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

This year, I tried "Sweet 100" and "Husky Cherry," and sweet 100 is much sweeter of the two.
Sweet 100 produced earlier than Husky Cherry, but the plant isn't as disease resistant and the fruits are smaller.
My in-laws visited a few weeks ago, and they all went crazy for Sweet 100 - they're so sweet and tasty, they're like fruit snacks. I'll probably repeat Sweet 100, but try Sungold with it the next year.
I think I've tried Supersweet 100 in the past, but I can't really measure it against sweet 100 side by side. I might try that experiment as well if I can't find Sungold nearby.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Here in South Central Pa. I've grown Black Cherry, Sun Gold, Snow White, Sweet 100's, Super Sweet 100's,Sweet million, Juliet, Yellow pear. The ones that keep getting planted year after year are Sun Gold(hybrid), and Black Cherry (heirloom). If I had to go with only one it would be Sungold, although prone to splitting after a rain or allowed to mature too much, just pick before rains or watering and you'll do fine. Happy Gardening!
Camo


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I had to chime in on this one -Purple Haze!
It's a little smaller than golf ball size, very productive and one darn healthy plant.
Sure, I like sungold as an old stand by but PH is a sweet/tart beauty that's going to go in again next season.
The only drawback is I only planted 1 to try it!


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Are Reisentraubes any good? I like the sound of 40 per cluster, and the rich tomato taste not usually found in cherry tomatos. I'll have to grow a good flavor-packed cherry next year as well; I love that sweet/tang flavor as well.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Here's the JTMacc99 list:

Every year: Sungold

Almost every year: Black Cherry (from TGS)

At least once every three years: Sugary (having a standard red grape is nice), Juanne Flammee, Green Grape.

I don't grow the nice red hybrid varieties, because I would end up using them for the same things as the Sungolds. I suppose they could share that job, but the fact is, I would end up using every last Sungold before I started to use the red ones, so they mostly go to waste.


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Is there more than one Galina? Sometimes I see Galina's, or Galina's Yellow, or just Galina. I also saw Galina Grand. Which is the Galina that most people like?


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Is there more than one Galina? Sometimes I see Galina's, or Galina's Yellow, or just Galina. I also saw Galina Grand. Which is the Galina that most people like?

****

Galina's Yellow, Galina, Galina's are all the same variety.

And a Galina's Lellus has been listed in the SSE YEarbooks as well, but the person who gave the seeds to the person who listed them I'm pretty sure is Amish and I think the word lellus means yellow or alternatively Lellus is a family name. It's still Galina's Yellow/

DonnaMarie, I'd never heard of a Galina Grand so Googled it and found it at Bountiful Gardens.

I don't know why they altered the name, and they've done that with a few other varieties as well, but that's Galina's Yellow.

There's only ONE Galina's or however folks want to express the name of that variety.

I stiull use Galina's Yellow b'c that's the name that Bill McDorman used when he brought back the variety from Siberia and initially offered it and all the others ones he brought back at High Altitude Seeds, now Seeds Trust/

Carolyn


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I'm confused. This site says it's a red:

http://davesgarden.com/guides/pf/go/120070/


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

It's a completely different variety also called Galina and you can see it's not the Galina we're talking about from Dill's comment:

On Dec 17, 2005, Farmerdill from Augusta, GA
(Zone 8a) wrote:
A 150 -200 g round red fresh market hybrid from Hazera.

The Galina we're talking about is OP and gold and from Siberia while the Galina Dill is talking about is an F1 market variety that's red, a hybrid and hybridized by Hazera Seeds which is in Israel.

Carolyn


 o
RE: Recommendations for best// Cherry Tomato?

DonnaMarie, below I've linked to the info and picture of Galina's Yellow which was right next to the Galina that you looked at in the DG Plantfiles.

Carolyn

Here is a link that might be useful: Galina's Yellow


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Thank you, Carolyn


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Hi,I was looking for the black cherry tomatoes that everyone is raving about, and got these -
but they are listed as chocolate cherry and not black cherry. I am assuming there is a difference? has anyone tried the chocolate cherry? Should I ditch them and go black cherry?

Here is a link that might be useful: chocolate cherry (parks)


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

I have little people in my life so my cherry tomato criteria have changed over the course of time. I was always a fan of Dr. Carolyn (another Galinas relative), Green Grape, Reisentraube (although seedy, it tastes really good), etc.
Few years ago someone GAVE me plants (they said they were dr carolyn, but they were clearly YELLOW PEAR) and of course the little people LOVED them...
Last year I grew Black Cherry, Green Grape, Sungold, Isis Candy, and Dr. Carolyn and the only one that was a real stand out was the Sungold. Black cherry wasn't prolific and they're BIG for a cherry... Green Grape tasted great, but again not prolific last year. I wasn't impressed with Dr. Carolyn or Isis Candy last year either. All that being said, it was a terrible tomato growing season for me - so who's to say why they were not prolific & not stand outs.
I'm now looking for small cherries - the size of Sungold... so I'm growing THIS YEAR Sungold, Hawaiian, Mexican Cocktail, for the small size... then I'm growing Green Doctors (b/c I DO like the Galinas/Dr.Carolyn group), and a few other crosses that a friend shared with me.
A friend was asking me for Matt's Wild Cherry - is that a current tomato?


 o
RE: Recommendations for best Cherry Tomato?

Purple Haze, because it's phenomenal.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here