Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Most Popular Tomato

Posted by goodground z6 NJ (My Page) on
Tue, Aug 5, 14 at 21:48

Besides all the well deserved Brandy Boy hype recently sparked by Hudson's AWESOME grow & pics, I think Cherokee Purple is still one of the most popular tomatoes on these boards. I too will be hunting down Brandy Boys seeds for next year. :-)

Here is a link that might be useful: My Cherokee Purples


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Also growing Gypsy for the first time since they sent a free pack of seeds. So far not as large as CP but more productive. This plant has multiple clusters of 8 with about 50 total. Brandy Boy will take their spot next year.

Here is a link that might be useful: My Gypsy's


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

g...I agree with CP being an awesome tomato. I am no mater expert (7 varieties last year and 8 this year). But, I like my CP's the best. I am still trying to like my Mortgage Lifter. I think they are getting better with time...but maybe I should pick with green shoulders. I may have let some get over-ripe.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Goodground,

I agree with you. From all the posts and comments here, I can say that Cherokee Purple is very popular. In the grape size Sun Gold is also seems o be the most popular.

BTW, I am growing both of those. So far no ripe CP in my garden but have been picking SG from mid July. I like them. Not very sweet but really tasty.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Fireduck,
I was told by my wife that I let my toms get too ripe. This year I have been picking everything that blushes because I can't wait. lol

Seysonn,
Picked my first CP to ripen on counter today. Already tasted about half dozen Gypsy but they were small. Plenty of both to come.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Talking about Most Popular.
Here is a picture of some Cherokee Purple on one of my plants. The are big. Over one pound each for sure. But not ripe (sigh)


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

CP are my best perfomers.
Great taste. Also earliest to ripen.
Also grew Moskvich. Nice flavor, decent production.
Brandywine, only a handful of BIG maters.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Goodground - your CPs look awesome! I am also a fan of CPs - I wish I could grow them a great as you and Seysonn! They do OK in our GH - but one has to figure out what varieties grow the best in ones climate! We only planted one CP plant this year and have enjoyed the taste immensely - I would grow more of them but my wife does not care for the color or taste of the CP - but tolerates them for me :)

 photo IMG_0992_zpscd1bcedd.jpg


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Hudson. your CPs look delicious.
I can't wait for mine to ripen. Any day now. But on the positive note, we've been enjoying Sun Gold, another big favorite, for a month now.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

delete dble post

This post was edited by seysonn on Thu, Aug 7, 14 at 19:39


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

From reading, as well as "Personal Experience", I think another very popular tomato is the Kellogg's Breakfast.

We've had a "banner year" as far as tomato production goes, and have given away a lot of tomatoes, (all beefsteaks of various types).

When my wife or I ask (whoever we gave the tomatoes to)
"Which tomato did you like best"?, the answer has been, "Kellogg's Breakfast".
It is also my wife's favorite tomato. They tend to be large, (one was 1.4 lbs), and most about a pound or close to it. Only my Green Giant tomato has produced more.

Gary


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Hudson, my wife feels the same way about the CP's that's why I am going to plant Brandy Boy's next year per your recommendation. If they come out like yours, I'm sure she will like them. Happy growing!


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

I had 17 CP plants this yr and most did very well. I too had some big fruit from these. I love the taste. Next for me are the red/yellow bi color. I like the pinks and reds too but I am a sweet tomato fanatic.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

  • Posted by babyg U10 S20/21 (MtnTop L (My Page) on
    Fri, Aug 8, 14 at 20:46

I grow sungold and sweet 100 and a dozen or more full size heirlooms. But darnit -- sweet cherry 100 is my son's and husband's favorite.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

I agree goodground - Brandy Boy is a good option - hope they grow good in your area! They even look good to eat and have a great tomato taste - I think she will like them - I would bet on it - if she likes tomatoes - she will like Brandy Boy!

 photo image_zps4f8397fa.jpg


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Gary, I think you are right about " Kellogg's Breakfast. ". I have not grown it but have read so many positive reviews on it in the past.

So here we go: I will add "Brandy Boy", Kellogg's Breakfast to my "KEEP" list of Siletz, Cherokee Purple, Sun Gold, Matina, Bloody Butcher.
Few are still being observed for taste and performance : Legend, Siberian and Mortgage Lifter (RC), Bush Steak, Husky Red.

Because of my space shortage, I am focusing more on determinants and semis like: Siletz, Husky, Bush steak, Siberian, Legend. I am also growing a red cherry from store bought heirloom, that is semi-det and prolific as well.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Boy!!! Awsome "pickins' Hudson, I want to try a Brandyboy next year, but I DON"T want the kind of production you are getting, (I'm tired of delivering maters to the neighbors)!!!

So how would you compare taste of the CP to BK, Seyson?
CP will probably be on my grow list next year, alto I sure like the taste, juiciness, texture , inside color of the BK and On and On~~~~~~all except for small sized maters this year~~~Maybe they sold me a "Midget BK", ya thinks?

Gary


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

So how would you compare taste of the CP to BK, Seyson?
%%%%%%%%%%

I would say they are about the same.
The reason that I am growing BK, is because of poor yield, cracking and small fruits.


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

"The reason that I am growing BK, is because of poor yield, cracking and small fruits"?

I "assume" that you meant, "The reason I'm NOT Growing BK next year is because~~~~~"???

Thanks!

Gary


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

Right, Gary, "...reason I am NOT ...."


 o
RE: Most Popular Tomato

My Top 5:

1. Mortgage Lifter
2. Celebrity
3. Park’s Whopper
4. Rose
5. Giant Belgium


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here