Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Posted by Corgikarma none (My Page) on
Fri, Oct 11, 13 at 14:31

Does anyone know where to find seeds that ship to the US?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

The only source Tania lists is Heritage Harvest in Canada, but as you know they do not ship to the US.

Please read the thread on Late Tomatoes here on the first page for more info about it in terms of seed that might be possibly available in the future.

Carolyn


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

I wish I had had a good enough season to save seeds. Really like this one and sad that I may not be able to grow it again. If I have any seeds left for next year, I hope someone reminds me to save the seeds, lol. To be honest, until I just saw this post I had forgotten that it was not available any more. Maybe someone will pop up to sell it for next year if they grew it out this year.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

I don't know about the "ESTILER's" version , both seeds and seedling for ML were available this past season, even at the big box nurseries. I clearly remember Fred Myers(Kroger) had plenty of them. Tat is why I am not going to start from seed but wait and buy plants instead.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

There are about 15 "versions" of ML if youlook at Tania's website and most of them, but not all, just carry the name of the person who first listed it in the SSE Yearbooks, And there are several persons I know who have grown out many of them in the same season for comparison and find llittle difference.

But the Estler one I and quite a few others like more than others that we've grown in terms of taste, production and consistent high yields,

Carolyn.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

I've got seeds but they are very old-probably over 12 years old.

These go way back to the Internet Tomato Trials. Frankly, I was one of those individuals that grew out several varieties of Mortgage Lifter side by side for comparison. Radiator Charlies was the star for me and I have stuck with it ever since when tempted to grow some Mortgage Lifters.

If you would like my seeds I will root through my freezer storage area for them. On the other hand, if you really want to try a couple of excellent red beefsteaks I'd suggest
Lil's Favorite or Big Beef Hybrid.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

The way I understand Morgage lifter is just a common term used in the past for farmers who were supplementing their income with side jobs as selling tomatoes or baking etc. So that creates confusion as tomatoes all different and have no ties except the name?
I got ML this year from a friend to taste, no idea which one that was, was very nice and pleasant beefsteak but had no wow factor compare lets say to Marianne Peace which is about standard in late tomato taste for me.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Mortgage Lifter is a very specific name, and not a general one for farmers trying to make money.

There is no information on why the Estler one was named Mortgage Lifter but there is for theRadiator Charlie one, which is all folks knew before the Estler one appeared.

Jeff McCormack intervied M. C Byles, Radiator Charlie, and related the info he got to his then SESE seed site, link at thebottom.

A mortgage is something that one takes out to buy a home or whatever, and then pays it off over time. As you'll see from the link at the bottom, that's exactly what M.C. Byles did,ans in paying off, or lifting, his mortgage.

Tania indicates all the various Mortgage Lifters in this link and all of them, except Estler's are essentially the same,with just the name of the person who SSE listed it as partof the ML name.

http://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Mortgage_Lifter,_Radiator_Charlie%27s

Summary?

Just one name, Mortgage Lifter, and different versions of that same one as first listed by different folks who had grown it in their own gardens.

And yes,there is some confusion since the Estler one was said to bedeloped in1922,see theTania link and much more, and the Radiator Charlie one about 10 years lat ger, both using the name Mortgage Lifter.

I don't think that will ever be solved.

Carolyn

Here is a link that might be useful: M L info from SESE


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

mmm, I happen to have Amy Goldman ¨Heirloom tomato...¨book and this is what she writes:
¨Morgage lifter¨is a generic term that refers to a set of big old tomatoes, characteristically pink, from central Appalachia. Radiator Charlie´s ML is the best known....
M.C. Byles did not invent the term, commodities that generate extra income for farmers, such as hogs, corn, or beans, have traditionally been labeled ¨mortgage lifters¨
Amy cites article ¨The Mortgage lifter: A man and his tomato¨ by John Marra for 1994 story for Goldenseal where it says that Bill Estler offered his seeds to grow by local greenhouse and when greenhouse worker Shorty Meadows brought him tray of transplants he said ¨I´ve brought you your mortgage lifters¨ Bill fell for the name and made it his own¨


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Carolyn, yes it IS solved. Estler's was first. It's been well-documented but people still insist on repeating an erroneous story about that imposter Byles. GRRR. It was a huge error by a stupid lawyer that allowed others to hijack the Mortgage Lifter name. My Grandfather was too trusting... but one can't turn back the clock to right old wrongs, unfortunately. All we can do is keep repeating the truth and hoping for the best.

Edie


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

mmm, I happen to have Amy Goldman ¨Heirloom tomato...¨book and this is what she writes:
¨Morgage lifter¨is a generic term that refers to a set of big old tomatoes, characteristically pink, from central Appalachia. Radiator Charlie´s ML is the best known....
M.C. Byles did not invent the term, commodities that generate extra income for farmers, such as hogs, corn, or beans, have traditionally been labeled ¨mortgage lifters¨
Amy cites article ¨The Mortgage lifter: A man and his tomato¨ by John Marra for 1994 story for Goldenseal where it says that Bill Estler offered his seeds to grow by local greenhouse and when greenhouse worker Shorty Meadows brought him tray of transplants he said ¨I´ve brought you your mortgage lifters¨ Bill fell for the name and made it his own¨

&&&&&

I happen to have Amy's book as well, she autographed it and probably b'c I helped her do research for her prior three books. and have know her since about 1990 when she used to drive up to my place near Albany and take home fruits from my plants to save seeds from/

But the Amy of today is not the Amy I once knew and we've had no contact, in many years now/

There are many many errors in her book as others have also pointed out, I'm not going to list them here. Amy had paid researchers who did most of the research and quite simply they goofed in many instances and Amy didn't know any differently so let the goofs stand.

Amy wrote"

(¨Morgage lifter¨is a generic term that refers to a set of big old tomatoes, characteristically pink, from central Appalachia. Radiator Charlie´s ML is the best known...)

And with the above comment I strongly disagree, Ask youself why she listed so many ML's in her book with the names of the persons who first listed them in the SSE Yearbooks as part of the ML name.

How I wish I could give a link here that confirms what Marra said, but the main point is that the parents of the Estler one are completely different from the others and that's a VERY important point.

I have more to say but I think I'll just tape up my fingers right now. LOL

Carolyn, who did Google using different entry words and only got one hit, pigs, in entering....... mortgage Lifter refers to what plants and animals..

Here is a link that might be useful: Google Search


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Nice to see you posting Edie. I hope you got some fresh seed from your Estler's Mortgage Lifters!

DarJones


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Carolyn, thanks for clarifying! I was wondering if Estler's ML had different parentage than others or how many varieties people had in prehistoric times when there was no internet...


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

I don't have a dog in the Mortgage Lifter hunt but please allow me to interject that the term Mortgage Lifter has been a common term in agriculture since at least the late 1800s and has been used to refer to both livestock and crops, including:

Mortgage Lifter Oats, which were exhibited at the Universal and International Exposition at Paris in 1878.
Everett’s Mortgage Lifter Field Corn was in an experiment at the Texas agricultural experiment station in 1895.
In the 1900s dairy cattle were the queens of Mortgage Lifters.
Kansas Mortgage Lifter Wheat is mentioned in a 1904 Ohio agricultural experiment station bulletin.
Orpington chickens where advertised as Mortgage Lifters in The Country Gentleman in 1911.
During the 1920s hogs in general and Berkshire hogs specifically were referred to as Mortgage Lifters.
Perhaps most famously DeKalb seed corn's "winged ear" logo first made its debut in 1936, appearing in an ad in Prairie Farmer Magazine with the slogan, "DeKalb Quality Hybrids Will Be Your Mortgage Lifter."

Most of these and many more pre-date Mortgage Lifter Tomatoes of any variety.
Mike


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

OK, OK, I didn't look long enough to find all the other Mortgage Lifter animals and crops,LOL,so I've learned something too.

But we're speaking of tomatoes here, aren't we, and how there are many versions Ided by the individual names associated with almost all of them.

And all but one of them, the Estler one,have the same parents that stem from Radiator Charlies initial one, the Estler one having different parents.

And so it goes.(smile)

Thanks Mike,

Carolyn


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

It does not mater who was first. The two are different tomatoes. Radiator Charlies is a BIG beef steak. Then the biography of Mr. Estler Says he was born in 1884 and E.ML was introduced in 1922. That put Mr.. Estler at about 37 years of age. And We don't know how long did it take him to develop and stabilize it.

Radiator Charly is said to be born in 1874 and introduced his tomato around 1930, i.e, at the age of 56. It has also been said that he developed an orthodox method that shows his high level of IQ. Apparantly, he never gave a name to his tomato but hen aske about paying his mortgage of of the renues, he mentioned, he bough his house fo $6000 and payed off most of by revenues from sales of plants and seeds. It has been said that people drove couple of hundred miles to buy seedlings from him. This further shows that he was well known. He died in early 1970s.

P.S.
I have never before grown his ML, but I will next year.

This post was edited by seysonn on Wed, Oct 16, 13 at 4:58


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Estler´s is coming my way from Heritage Harvest and will be in very tough company of some serious contenders for next year.
Yes, at least you have history. I am still trying to figure out where famous black presumably russian tomatoes came from...
I know Tatiana tried to ask on some tomato russian forums and one person answered she has grown Black prince since about 1980 and one mentioned a book of 1968 circa on tomatoes where Tsygan- Gypsy in noted but other than that we still in the dark...LOL


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Dar, we only got enough ML chunks (cutting around the bad parts) to make a couple of salads, we could not salvage any for seeds due to gray mold from the unrelenting rain we got in early summer. I cried and cried the day we ripped all the plants out of the ground and burned them :(

Seysonn, I have a picture of my grandfather holding Estler's MLs that are at least twice the size of those in that picture. And that was/is not uncommon - Estler's are known for their size, taste and production. I will have to see if I can find that picture. I'm pretty sure I posted it once before. Yes, it took him a few years to stabilize his, he started working on them before my Dad was born, and that was in 1919.

Edie


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

I keep swearing to learn how to post pics and I will soon(I hope). Nothing wrong with the the fruit in the above pic but I do get larger Estlers than those and the avg is that good or better and a more globe, uniformed shape. Largest so far since I bought Paula Deen scales was 37 ounces and 5-6 inches in diameter. I sucker to 1-2 or three stems and get prob eight-12 tomatoes from a plant. Grow in improved clay soil where I have gardened since 1976. I have been deep plowing in April, then tilling in bagged manure and 6-10-10 ferilizer. I also get two pond yed/yellow tomatoes. But Estlers will always be my favorie. Cherokee Purple being a close second.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Estler´s is coming my way from Heritage Harvest and will be in very tough company of some serious contenders for next year.

$$$$$$

Hmmmm. You are in IL as I recall and Hertiage Harvest is in Canada and has been very strict in NOT sending seeds to the US.'So what did you say or do to persuade them to send you seeds? LOL

I know that there are many others who would like to know your secret to get them to send from Canada to the US. ( smile)

Carolyn


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

I thought I had a copy of the picture used in the Goldenseal article, but I don't, darn it. I do have this one of my Grandfather and one of my cousins with a few of his plants, this probably was back in the early 50's.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Good heavens Ediej1290. That "plant" looks like a tree. I grew Estler's this past season and was mighty impressed. Lovely tomato. Long story on getting the seeds, but I did finally get the correct one. Thanks for sharing your family story. Love the picture. Mary


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Wow, heck of tomato! Beautiful memories!
Carolyn, re seeds from Canada...where is will there is way, my seeds are making detour to Canadian addy and thanks to a kind GW member traveling to its final destination later on. The company had some really interesting varieties including 2 Russian ¨exclusives¨ which may or may not be but am interested to see... Yagodka, Sara Black, Prudence Purple and few others going to have fine company with load of Russian tomatoes I got from Tanya.


 o
RE: Estler's Mortgage Lifter

Love that picture. Hopefully one day we can get
the Estler's that edie has circulated around the
tomato forums, so we can all try this tomato.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Growing Tomatoes Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here