Return to the Tropicalesque Garden Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Posted by cheerpeople 5a (My Page) on
Fri, Dec 23, 05 at 18:00

I just finished reading the new 05 book "Hot plants for Cool Climates". I am not familiar with these plants listed in the next several posts.

I am familiar with some other tropicals listed in the book and my own experience has been different especially with PLANT SIZE than what this book claims. I thought perhaps your experience could enlighten me. Maybe there are some good plant suggestions in this book or maybe it wasn't really written with zone 5 in mind....


Sugarcane-
I read this. Is it true? The botanical name is saccharem officinarum. It says it can be stored in a pot dry and dark over the winter in cold zones.

LMK your experience with this- supposed to look like bamboo.
Thx karen


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Hello, I want to thank you for the name of this book cause I did'nt know that book and now I order it. I don't know if you are in the USA or Canada but it makes a difference between the zone, a zone 5B cdn is a 4B USA. And I beleive this book is from USA, and it does make a difference between the zone, per exemple a Bamboo «Phyllostachys nuda» in a zone 5b cdn will grow about 8 feet tall, but the more the zone is high and the more tall it will grow, and I beleive it apply for other plants as well. I don't know if I answer your question, but that was my first time writing here.

Cheers

Denis


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Denis,

Thx for the info on the bamboo.

I agree the zone makes a difference on the height so I thought I should ask what you've experienced. I have heard the cold zones are different out of the US- the book was written in the US. But many of the pics are from much warmer zones than here.

I'm glad I could help.
I made a mistake tho, It was published in 2000 not 2005.


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Actually, I will plant my first Musa Basjoo next spring, right now it's in the garage, among Datura, Canna and few other kind. I'll said that with that Musa, that will be my first real experience with hardy tropical. My garden right now have a lot of evergreen, like rhododendron or boxes and others. I live in Montreal, where are you from, if I may ask? And talking about book I have the book «Palms Won't Grow Here and Other Myths» and I'm ordering at the same time as the book you reffered to me, another book named: «Hardy Palms and Palm-Like Plants».

Cheers


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Denis,
I see you are new to GW --welcome!
I'm in the midwest- Illinois.

You can find lots of nice books by listing the subject 'gardening' at Amazon.com

I then ask my librarian to do an interlibrary loan for ones available so I have winter reading to do from all the books I can find in my half of the state!

You'll have to let me know how your Musa does.


karen


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Yes that's exactly where I'm going to order it from (Amazon) great choice and good price, but when I first did my research, the title of your book never appeared. I also have a lot of books and magazines about plants and landscaping, but it's seems I never have enough :) They are my precious. I'm french canadian, I speak very good english, but my writing is not the greatest, so I apologize for my misswriting sometime.

Ciao


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Denis,
Canadian, eh?!
Here is another book that has great info and maybe the height info is more in line with what we see here in colder zones. 'Right plant, Right place" revised 2005!
To bad I have to return it to the library soon it is chock full of info. Might be of interest to you $30.

Also there is a yahoo group for cold climate gardens. We have a chat on Monday's now. Many folks there are from canada too.

I haven't tried a musa. I don't like the ripped up leaves just intact leaves and we have so much wind. I'm growing a giant bird of paradise instead- should have it to a big size in another million years!Right now it's a beautiful houseplant.
Karen


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

yes, it's true. You can get the same results.

Here are photos that I took in my friend's east central Iowa (zone 4b) garden. His plants get massive each year. Cannas, sugar cane, bananas, castor beans etc.. No prob at all!

Go for it!

Boca Joe

Here is a link that might be useful: Coopman Cay Central Iowa


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Karen, I ordered the book, and I can wait to receive it. There was two books with the same title, I think it's the same book just $35.00 differents!

And Boca Joe, this is the most beautiful garden (for the same weather as mine), I will put it in my favorite and it will most defenately inspired me, You tell your friend.

Ciao


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

  • Posted by baci z10Ca (My Page) on
    Sat, Jan 7, 06 at 8:06

You need to be good at fertilizing – sugar cane is a heavy feeder. If you have Mexican markets in your area, they sell sugar cane around Xmas & it might be a cheap way to get a cane.
My sugar cane was about 3 ft the first year, & it took 3 years to reach 6 ft. I have a couple of varieties that are in pots.


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Baci- When you say get one from a mexican market...I have seen them at walmart as a cut off stem in the fruit stand. Do you root those?
I'm not sure about a mexican market- this is smalltown USA!

I will be in CA in April- if I find somethng there- should it be rooted? Which grow thick canes and the fastest that work out in pots?

thx:)
Karen


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

  • Posted by baci z10Ca (My Page) on
    Sun, Jan 8, 06 at 8:31

Hi Karen

I have bought pieces of cut up cane (3-4 inches) & tried to root them without success. You need a couple of nodes, so it is better to get a whole stalk. You can order them online, but they are expensive, & I would only do this for an unusual variety. The canes I have seen online were about $25.00, but this was for the black or another unusual variety. I have seen them sell for $5.00 for a 5 gallon pot at swap meets, or $2.00 for a cane in the grocers. I root my canes by cutting them with a hacksaw so they have a couple of nodes, & place them at an angle in a pot of spaghnum peat moss. I mention the grocery because this is only time of year I have seen them in markets. I saw one at the store 2 days ago, & it looked a bit puny but it would probably take.
If you care to e-mail me about your travel location, I can look & see if I can find a source near you. There also several varieties of eucalyptus growing out here, although it is a menace as every years the trees fall over & kill people or damage property.


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

baci,
The best way to root sugarcane is to lay the cutting horizontal and cover the whole piece with soil about 2 inches. The roots emerge from the nodes--just like the sprouts do. The sprouts will emerge even if planted deeper. ( I grow 2 acres of sugarcane in NW FL )
You might want to read the online pamplet "Backyard Sugarcane" for some more helpful info.

Here is a link that might be useful: Backyard Sugarcane


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

Sugarcane52 Thanks for the online pamplet, I got some sugarcain from Boca Joe and tried to get em to grow without success, I do'nt know why but this is a plant I'm going to keep trying untill I get it right.
Thanks again for the Pamplet


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

  • Posted by baci z10Ca (My Page) on
    Sun, Jan 14, 07 at 8:20

sugarcane52, thanks for the link. I know that most growers root theirs by laying theirs down flat, & it is convention to do so. If you know of a site that would help ID sugar cane I would like to know of it.
In zone 5, it would probably need to be container grown. The link above is gone, but the grower is probably growing indoors or planting out.


 o
RE: zone 5 sugarcane get's 4-6 ft tall in a summer?

baci,
Sorry, I didn't get back to you sooner, got busy, I guess. I just tried the link above and it still worked for me. As for id'ing sugarcane...good luck ! There are so many varieties that even experts rarely will try. I have over 100 varieties though and some literature that may help in id'ing varieties. If I can help, let me know. What kinds do you have ?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Tropicalesque Garden Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here