JOIN NOW LOG IN
iVillage GardenWeb iVillage GardenWeb THE INTERNET'S GARDEN & HOME COMMUNITY ADVERTISEMENT
Blogs Forums Photo Galleries Ask The Experts Tools & Directories        
Return to the Vines Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

Posted by lafleuriste 5 western NY (My Page) on
Sat, Jun 20, 09 at 22:13

I got my first moon flower blossom tonight. I began these seeds in February, and have been eagerly awaiting the creamy white blooms and heavenly scent I keep hearing of...I even felt like ordering a drumroll, Clark Griswold-style before bending down to smell the flower.

It doesn't smell like much of anything. Well, if I stick my nose right in, I catch a faint whiff of something that smells like plastic.

Even worse, I think it's just me. My husband says he can smell it and that it smells like a really good air freshener.

What's wrong with my nose? I'm so bummed. I'll keep sniffing the blooms as they open this summer, but I'm starting to think I don't have the can-smell-moonflowers gene.

Just letting off some steam...thanks for your sympathy.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

  • Posted by carrieb 7 Philadelphia (My Page) on
    Sun, Jun 21, 09 at 13:49

A few weeks ago, my boss commented about how "fragrant" Scotch broom is. I looked at her and said "are you being sarcastic?" I hate the smell! Funny how different things smell good or bad to each of us. I like the smell of moonflowers.


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

My mom loves the scent of moonflowers, but I can't smell them AT ALL. On the other hand, I like the scent of privet hedge blooms, but she thinks they smell like dirty socks.


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

Wow! How'd you get the thing to bloom so early? What kind of sun does it get?

I never have blooms til Sept. I just figured it bloomed based on day length or something.


 o
RE: Moonflower Doesn't Smell - ? tobacco or medication related ?

How many of you who can't smell moomflowers are cigarette smokers (?)
There are no 2 people that have the same exact sense of smell or taste , although tobacco cigarette smoking (or chewing tobacco) and taking certain medication can definitely reduce / alter both the sense of smell and taste...both of which are a type of chemo-reception...

Just some aspects to consider...


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

Lafleuriste, one thought. Maybe when your plant has a few blooms open at once the scent will be more intense and then you'll be able to smell it. I hope I'll be able to smell mine when it blooms. I know that sometimes all those write ups on those seed packets about how a plant blossoms will smell your entire yard are sort of hype.


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

Thanks, all. I'm hanging on to hope that I'll be able to smell the subsequent blooms! I've never smoked, so I don't think it's that. I agree that to my nose, privet hedges or boxwood (something that grows in the South) really stinks, like msbatt said of her mom, so maybe it's just my own individual sense of smell.

I have sweet peas to console me though, blooming in lovely pinks and purples and they smell delightful - Old Spice variety.

October17: I started these moon flower seeds way back in February and had been growing them under lights for the remainder of the winter. By the time I planted them out, they were already a few feet tall. I'd read that if I want blooms all summer (here in my northern climate), I'd better start way early!


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

I've never been a smoker, but my mom smoked for 50 years. (And she can smell a gnat fart in a hurricane!) I do, however, have some serious sinus problems.


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

Just smelled my aunt's moon flower plant in New Bern, NC--smelled exactly like "bergamot"--ie. like Earl Grey Tea! MmmmMmmm! Gorgeous!


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

My nose doesn't get a whole of fireworks from Ipomoea alba, either - just a faint whif of something barely tinged with lavender.

So, what I like to do is to plant other fragrant moonflowers, along with Ipomoea alba. For example, whereas the Japanese call Ipomoea nil, Asagao (morning face), they apply the name, moonflower, to a night-flowering gourd "Fugao" (evening face, aka Lagenaria siceraria) It has sort of a fruity smell. See http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Yoshitoshi_The_Ghost.jpg - How's that for a moody night vine?

An unusual 4'oclock has decided to keep coming back over our winters here from its tubers, as well as by self-sown seed - Mirabilis longiflora - looonnng tubes with little flares at their tips that smell of orange blossoms.

The scents of each of these are small to my nose, but together I get quite a treat. Hopefully next year I'll get Evening Stock (Matthiola incana aka M. bicornis) to start self-sowing over our winters and join the chorus.

Even if we can't smell these flowers, watching them unfurl around or after sunset is another treat to enjoy.

Karen


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

  • Posted by glen3a Winnipeg MB 3A (My Page) on
    Wed, Sep 2, 09 at 21:48

Well you are not going to believe this, but my moonflower has bloomed a few blossoms now and to be honest, I don't smell a thing. Maybe it's because it's been a cool summer, so most evenings when the blossoms open it's already cooling off (I know heat sometimes makes things smell more fragrant). Anyway, I will definitely plant it again next year, because the blossoms are huge. I may mix the plant with a morning glory which of course blooms during the day.

My nicotiana will definitely be back next year. I planted small plants that I started from seed and as you probably know, they grow quick. It seems for quite a few evenings if you went by the plants you can smell their fragrance.

Maybe that will be a good way to pass time this winter, researching fragrant plants on the internet for next year.

Glen


 o
RE: My Moonflower Doesn't Smell Like I Thought It Would...

Glen, so true about the nicotiana - how could I forget that one? Mine has been self-sowing for years, and one plant outsmells a store-bought plant of white heliotrope quite a bit at night(not that I advise anyone to go without white heliotrope in a moon garden - by day it wins hands-down).

One thing about searching the internet for fragrant plants - it helps to know what you're looking for. I think I spent around $7 for Louise Beebe Wilder's classic The Fragrant Path. It's old, comes as a paperback facsimile and mentions tons of plants once common back in the late 19th to early 20th centuries, but many of which are unheard of now.

For one thing, many retailers are pushing recent hybrids, not heirlooms or species once common in our grandmothers' gardens. Armed with Wilder's book, not only will your internet searches be more fruitful, but you'll be able to identify these plants when they come up in seed exchanges that only give you a list of plant names in Latin, as well as look them up in HortPlex (spelling) or PlantFiles.

There are quite a few seed exchanges, but for starters, I recommend the North American Rock Garden Society (NARGS) - http://www.nargs.org/ . They say they prefer rock plants, but you can find a huge variety of plants there anyway suited to almost any kind of habitat or garden style you can imagine.

Apologies for being windy - hope this helps anyone who might not have known all this up until now...so many kinds of moonflowers and their companions

Karen


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Vines Forum
 
 


iVillage GardenWeb: The Internet's Garden & Home Community  
  iVillage Home & Garden Network