Return to the Woodlands Forum | Post a Follow-Up

Relating tree species to soils

Posted by Sujiwan 6-7 MD (My Page) on
Wed, Jan 4, 06 at 11:04

I've been trying to figure out where to find a soils map for Adams County, PA that I can then localize to my newly acquired "farm". Conversely, I've been looking at the natives growing that I can easily identify, wondering what it tells me about the soil.

This farm is part of a wide valley and has a meandering stream running through it which apparently overflows at times and covers part of the treed area. The pasture across the road near me often seems to have a fair amount of standing water to drain off. The trees found on my side are huge black walnut and hickory trees, unidentified species and a bunch of low growing unknown shrubs/ wild rose bushes. I always thought that black walnut liked deep, rich, moist soils and hickory were more upland. For black walnut to thrive, would this mean that the flooding is infrequent and short lived?

Away from the stream areas, I think the property had several acres of low pasture which is colonized by lots of skinny trees. It looks like maybe some sort of maple. I don't see any evergreens or oak. We're talking about clearing out and reclaiming some land for alternative uses like pasture or chosen habitat plantings with more variety.

Right now, all I know is that the soil on the dwelling side of the road is dark brown and crumbly while the stream banks on the other side are yellowish clay (Kaolin?) and the ground under trees is woodland duff covered brown.

Sorry for the ramble, but I'm hoping someone can point me toward some information about what I've got to work with based on the little bit of shared info here. What do volunteer tree types tell us about what else we can do with that habitat?

Follow-Up Postings:

RE: Relating tree species to soils

Plants can definitely be used as indicators of the type of soil and amount of moisture/flooding in a given location, but trees aren't always very helpful in this regard, at least in the Northeast. Certain trees do prefer certain types of habitats, but the trees may not precisely conform to the boundaries of the soils, and most tree species here in PA can grow in more than one type of soil and moisture regime. For example, Eastern Sycamore is typically found in moist soils, especially riparian areas (areas influenced by surface water). However, one can often find sycamores growing outside of riparian areas, particularly when there is a good stand of Sycamores nearby to supply seeds. Same goes for Black Walnut, which seems most common in deep, moist soils near rivers and streams, but can also occur in uplands. What's even worse, walnuts are often planted by humans and the nuts may be carried by squirrels. Trees are an indication of soil type, but not absolute proof.

In addition to soil and moisture, another major influence on the type of trees in a location is recent history. If a site was cleared of all trees, for instance cleared for pasture, then the first trees that might recolonize the site might be trees with seeds that are dispersed by the wind, or they might be the offspring of whatever trees were left standing nearby. If you have a stand of young maples, that might be an indication that a few maples were the only trees left in the pasture and therefore were in the right place to supply lots of seeds when the pasture was abandoned. In fact the pasture might have had very few maples when it was a forest.

Yet a third major influence on the type of trees growing in an area is predation - I'm talking about deer and perhaps cows. Lots of PA forests are growing black cherry and red maple after they are logged not because these are historically the dominant trees in the area, but because these trees are less palatable to deer and therefore are the only ones that survive heavy browsing by deer. Don't underestimate the impact deer may be having on the trees - they can be surprisingly hard to see even when very numerous. Cattle also can have an influence on trees - many former cow pastures are now stands of Red Cedar because cows avoid eating red cedar, allowing red cedar to repopulate the pasture even while the cows are still present. As soon as the farmer stops occasional mowing -viola, the baby red cedars can grow and you have a red cedar forest.

Finally, there are many types of hickories and they favor different types of soils. If you have a stand of walnut and hickory on former farmland, I might suspect that the previous owner of the land selectively saved walnuts and hickories because he liked nuts or liked hunting. Walnuts and hickories are both good for squirrels and generally recommended by game management literature.

I think if you want to use trees as indicators of the soil and moisture you should focus not on individual species, but on the communties of trees on your land. If you find red oak, white oak, chestnut oak, certain hickories, pitch pine and/or virginia pine dominating an area you might expect to find drier soils typical of uplands. If you have a stand of Eastern Sycamore, Silver maple, American Elm, and perhaps walnuts too, then you might expect to have moister soils and occasional to frequent flooding. If you see one set of tree species in the canopy and another in the seedlings, then you might either have a forest going through natural succession or some force (deer or the recent removal of a lot of the deer or cows) influencing the forest composition.

Hope this helps...

RE: Relating tree species to soils

The National Resources Conservation Service (formerly Soil Conservation Service) publishes soil surveys of each county. This link indicates that the one for Adams county is out of print:

You should be able to locate one at the USDA Service Center in the link below. If they don't have one, your nearest library probably does. I don't know if they will be the same as the soil survey for my county, but if they are, they will have all the information you are looking for. They have detailed maps, plant association with soil types, detailed descriptions of each soil type, etc.

Here is a link that might be useful: USDA Service Center

RE: Relating tree species to soils

Thanks so much for the information and for the detailed post. My neighbor tells me that our woods are alive with deer which makes me wonder how successful I would be attempting any (costly) planting. I dearly love the viburnum family for woods edge and was also thinking of elderberry and at least one willow near the water. Do you think everything mentioned would be eaten to nubs by deer?

RE: Relating tree species to soils

you may find your property is mapped as an on-line resource. this site has been up for less than a year, i think. not the easiest to navigate but can be fun if you find your property in the database.
you can select your applications such as farming, livestock, timber, etc.
also, that would be "natural", not "national" resources conservation service if you go looking for more information. ;-)

Here is a link that might be useful: web soil survey

RE: Relating tree species to soils

Deer are not big fans of viburnum as the whole genus is a little hairy in the leaf, try some and wait. Arrowood or highbush cranberry should even survive a browse or two, I suspect, especially in high density bottomland...

The USDA Plant database also has listings for whether a plant is a wetlands indicator that are used for official assessments; that might be definitive... I think Ladyslipper is right, perennials would be more telling...

 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!

Return to the Woodlands Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.

Learn more about in-text links on this page here