Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
apprehend

It was just all too nice.

apprehend
20 years ago

Included in the review of a book I was thinking of purchasing was the phrase "It was just all too nice"

I've been thinking about this ever since and while book reviews are not what you do here, understanding what attracts readers may be of interest.

I'm not sure if he was talking about her style of writing or her seeming lack of passion and controversy in a book about a subject often inducing both.

Do you need to be a gardener to enjoy the play of words that bring a picture to mind? When Beth Chatto speaks of a color near pewter, gray green with a touch of mauve, do only gardeners see or even care?

Is a gentle sense of fun or a dry acerbic wit more likely to your taste? And isn't this true whatever you are reading?

Can information be delivered with prose and poetry?

Do you ever think about this?

Comments (5)

  • acj7000
    20 years ago

    Very nicely put.
    There is no doubt in my mind that even garden books can be written to convey the writers passion with wit and I dare say it could also be poetic. I wonder sometimes why we settle for less.
    There are garden writers who carry us along with their enthusiasm; I wouldn't say that Ken Druse is a great writer, yet somehow his books are compelling. In "The Education of a Gardener" Russell Page's schoolboy like enthusiasm makes the words jump off the page but once again I wouldn't call it literature. Karel Capek and Henry Mitchell add a humourous scene that we can easily see ourselves in, even playing a starring role! There is more to gardening and garden writing than the nice 'thank you for sharing' attitude that made Martha the moneyto play with.
    Yes, I think about this a lot.

  • apprehend
    Original Author
    20 years ago

    In 'Paradise By Design' I was captivated by landscape architecture, someone of college age could be lured into the professsion by such writing.
    In 'The Lost Garden' the gardens and knowledge of them are used to develope character and the story very successfully.
    Interests steer me in the direction of gardening,habit takes me to reading,writers make this a joy. An easier way of finding each other should be on the agenda.

  • eddie_ga_7a
    20 years ago

    Understanding what attracts readers is of great interest and it starts with the book title which must be enticing. Can information be delivered with prose and poetry? Witness this line by Hal Massie of Macon Georgia: "where the brown stalks of annuals and tender perennials stand testament to the power of frost." To me that is prose. For a touch of self-deprecating wit how about these lines I wrote: Just be careful not to overdo it. I know I certainly wonÂt be overdoing it because at my age Âafternoon delight means taking a nap. Glad to have your input to this forum apprehend.

  • apprehend
    Original Author
    20 years ago

    Maybe it starts with a title, but I haven't noticed that titles draw me to a book.Most titles tell you little and would need to be awful to turn me away from writing I have been taken to by another source. Where I become aware of them is what seems to spur interest.
    Was it in a magazine like 'Chicago Wilderness'?
    Did another writer quote from it?
    Did a gardener whose work I admire mention being spured to action by an author?

  • The_Mohave__Kid
    20 years ago

    I'm not sure if poetry does it for me when information is the goal but a good story really helps to move information in a dramatic way ... certainly there is a great elegance in the botanical world that should lend itself to prose and poetry ..... by the way Hello to all ... I'm new here .... hope to pick up a few tips !

    Good Day ....

Sponsored